A comparison of the essay of john roche and richard hofstadter

Kelly, and David C. King, "The Politics of Path Dependency:

A comparison of the essay of john roche and richard hofstadter

The Paranoid Style in American Politicsdescribe the provincialism in American society, warning it contains much anti-intellectual fear of the cosmopolitan city, presented as wicked by the xenophobic and anti-Semitic Populists of the s.

They trace the direct political and ideological lineage between the Populists and anti-communist Senator Joseph McCarthy and McCarthyismthe political paranoia manifest in his contemporary time. His dissertation director Merle Curti noted about Hofstadter that "His position is as biased, by his urban background While not publishing his harshest thoughts, Hofstadter said privately that Turner no longer was a useful guide to history, because he was too obsessed with the frontier and his ideas too often had "a pound of false-hood for every few ounces of truth.

He used them over and over: His goal, they argue, was "destroying certain cherished American traditions and myths derived from his conviction that they provided no trustworthy guide for action in the present. In the s Hofstadter abandoned political causes, feeling that intellectuals were no more likely to "find a comfortable home" under socialism than they were under capitalism.

The impact of these years created his orientation to the American past, accompanied as it was by marriage, establishment of life-style, and choice of profession. Although Hofstadter quickly became disillusioned with the Communist Party, he retained an independent left-wing standpoint well into the s.

A comparison of the essay of john roche and richard hofstadter

Beard as "the exciting influence on me. Beard encouraged historians to search for the hidden self-interest and financial goals of the economic belligerents. By the s and s Hofstadter had a strong reputation in liberal circles. He was a derisive critic and parodist of every American Utopia and its wild prophets, a natural oppositionist to fashion and its satirist, a creature suspended between gloom and fun, between disdain for the expected and mad parody.

Conservatism rose on a tide of votes cast by people irritated by the liberalism of condescension. His friend David Herbert Donald said, "as a liberal who criticized the liberal tradition from within, he was appalled by the growing radical, even revolutionary, sentiment that he sensed among his colleagues and his students.

He could never share their simplistic, moralistic approach. He even employed one, Mike Wallaceto collaborate with him on American Violence: A Documentary History ; about the book, Hofstadter student Eric Foner said that it "utterly contradicted the consensus vision of a nation placidly evolving without serious disagreements.

A Social Portrait See David S. Brown, Richard Hofstadter: An Intellectual Biography (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, ), pp. – As Brown notes, Hofstadter and Wallace, a doctoral student in history, were on opposite sides during the Columbia protests, with the book apparently an attempt by Hofstadter to insulate Wallace’s more radical activities.

An Analysis Of John Roche's Essay Education Articles | September 15, In John P. Roche's essay "A Reform Caucus in Action", he suggests that the constitutional framing process was a highly democratic process involving the interests of each state of in the Union. In a foreword to the twenty-fifth anniversary edition of Richard Hofstadter's American Political Tradition (), Christopher Lasch paid tribute to the late historian and teacher who, above all others, had provided a model for his own vocation. According to an essay by Rose Wilder Lane (Lane, ), “George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, James Madison, and James Monroe feared democracy.” The founders believed that the Constitution left all other governmental powers to .

Student Essays - U.S. Political Systems Professor Russell Renka Fall Fall Essay 1 - Question 1. John Roche said the Framers of the Constitution were pragmatic democrats, but Richard Hofstadter raised serious doubts about that, labeling them as economic upper-class defenders who feared the aggressive urban mobs and small dirt.

Essay about Richard Hofstadter's The Age of Reform. Length: words (6 double-spaced pages) Rating: Powerful Essays.

A comparison of the essay of john roche and richard hofstadter

Open Document. Essay Preview. Richard Hofstadter's The Age of Reform In , Richard Hofstadter wrote his Pulitzer Prize winning book The Age of Reform, about the Gilded Age. Hofstadter’s arguments about the Populist and.

In a foreword to the twenty-fifth anniversary edition of Richard Hofstadter’s American Political Tradition (), Christopher Lasch paid tribute to the late historian and teacher who, above all others, had provided a model for his own vocation.

An Analysis Of John Roche's Essay Education Articles | September 15, In John P. Roche's essay "A Reform Caucus in Action", he suggests that the constitutional framing process was a highly democratic process involving the interests of each state of in the Union.

Richard Hofstadter, my old mentor and perhaps the most intellectually dynamic of them all, somewhat hovered between the conflict and consensus scenarios. His American Political Tradition () suggested long-term continuities, perhaps of an unattractive variety.

Who was Richard Hofstadter? - Sample Essays