Debating sex and gender and after

Report this Argument Pro Please watch the videos when indicated, they are short but fit into, and are explained by that section. Thanks to Noumena for daring me to debate him, so that he could "pummel" me, as he put it.

Debating sex and gender and after

Report this Argument Pro Please watch the videos when indicated, they are short but fit into, and are explained by that section. Thanks to Noumena for daring me to debate him, so that he could "pummel" me, as he put it.

Debating Sex and Gender and After Identity Essay – Free Papers and Essays Examples

Overview In deciding this issue, it is important that we attempt to answer some critical questions. Although other questions will undoubtedly arise, over the course of this debate I will try to discuss and focus on the issues which I believe to be the most critical.

Is there a natural link between gender identity, expression, and sex? As per the rules, we are allowed to make no more than two arguments per round, so I will focus on those two questions, in this round.

We are debating those who Debating sex and gender and after the sex organs of one sex yet express themselves as a different sex. Claims of gender non-conformity fall into just a few categories [2].

Debating sex and gender and after

There are male-to-female MTFfemale-to-male FTM"genderqueer" GQthose who fall somewhere on the continuum between male and female, and cross-dressers CDthose who are comfortable with their biological sex but wish to express their feminine side through dressing as the opposite sex.

Transgendered people describe themselves in many ways, believe that gender and sex are not related, and try to disavow the "male-female binary". Whether they refer to biological sex or their gender identity, they do so using the male and female terms. To be blunt, people who are trying to portray themselves as the opposite sex from which they were born, tend to not be attractive as the opposite sex, nor do they have the ability to fulfill the reproductive role, of the opposite sex.

Debate Topic: Should Gender Identity be Predicated on Biological Sex?? | iridis-photo-restoration.com

Men are attracted to women who look and act like women, women are attracted to men who look and act like men. Pheremones and chemistry play a large part in attraction [3].

Debating sex and gender and after

Those laws of attraction are obvious, exist in every species, and are a necessary and natural part of the proliferation of all sexually reproducing organisms. That alone shows that there is a natural and necessary link between how gender is expressed, and biological sex.

For those reasons combined, it is reasonable to believe that a natural link between sex and gender is self-evident, which makes the next question even more germane to the issue.

From what I have seen, there is no solid evidence to show that there is a scientific basis for claiming that one is born one gender externally, but another internally.

People who are born clearly and unambiguously morphologically male, for instance, will invariably also be genetically and molecularly male, as well. Those are actual medical issues that can be tested for and diagnosed, and are not the subject of this debate.

While it is believed that hormones may play a role in gender identity, those who are diagnosed with gender identity issues are first checked for medical causes, and no medical or hormonal reason can be found to support a physical cause.

Many times gender identity disorder is accompanied by other major psychological issues, leading some professionals to the conclusion that incorrectable GID is over-diagnosed [4].

From an article at Child Healing In another study Dutch psychiatrists reported on patients with GID. Campo J, et al. Psychiatric co-morbidity of Gender Identity " Dr. True gender problems leading to the need for hormones and surgery is rare, approximately 1 in every 20, births, but if you walk down the hall of a normal high school, such as the one my wife teaches at, you would think there was an epidemic.

In this video you will see an obviously conflicted individual giving advice about being "trans" and how and when to make the choice. I think the obvious reason for that conflicting information is that, in truth, it is a choice.

For most who claim to be trans, it is simply a means to express their displeasure with gender roles, or rebel against societal expectations, etc.The Theories of Sex and Gender Sex and gender are two very separate factors in the debate of how gender acquisition occurs.

Sex is a biological fact determined by . The fifth volume in the Fundamentals of Philosophy Series, Debating Sex and Gender by Georgia Warnke is a concise yet in-depth introduction to contemporary feminist thought on sex and gender. Sex-gender issues in the society take specific stands (for example in questionnaires), while race or ethnicity is dynamic over time due to the changing nature of the society.

As Pro did not narrow it, either by definition, or by debating "Gender Roles Are a Social Construct", there is no reason to limit the debate to part of the meaning of gender. It is worth noting that all 4 sources used in this round, from fitness to government to medical, use gender and sex interchangeably. The Theories of Sex and Gender Sex and gender are two very separate factors in the debate of how gender acquisition occurs. Sex is a biological fact determined by the chromosomes inherited from parents. Gender is a complex issue and cannot be so easily explained by saying "gender and sex are the same, Therefore you are either a man or a woman". Two people can have very different ideas for what gender is based on their culture and what they were exposed to.

New race and ethnic choices are from time to time made available, but the sex-gender aspect remains the same. The Theories of Sex and Gender Sex and gender are two very separate factors in the debate of how gender acquisition occurs.

Sex is a biological fact determined by the chromosomes inherited from parents. Debating Sex and Gender and After Identity Words | 6 Pages. Name: Professor: Course: Date: In Debating Sex and Gender and After Identity, Dr.

Warnke presents various arguments that demonstrate how sex, gender, and race are all social constructs.

As Pro did not narrow it, either by definition, or by debating "Gender Roles Are a Social Construct", there is no reason to limit the debate to part of the meaning of gender.

It is worth noting that all 4 sources used in this round, from fitness to government to medical, use gender and sex interchangeably.

Debating Sex and Gender in Eighteenth-Century Spain by Marta V. Vicente